Pages

{BLOGGERVILLE} no picnik? a review of options

wwhhhaaaaaatt?
picnik is closing?
yes. it hurts me too.
what to do now? 

Pin It
so...
i am here to present my plan from a blogger perspective
many bloggers use picnik as a simple way to make photo collages, watermark / title our images,
resize photos, add artsy flare, and in some cases EDIT photos lol
if you rely on picnik, here are some almost equal replacements.

NOTE:
obviously, you can invest in photoshop, photoshop elements, lightroom ect. 
BUT i am looking today for a DIRECT replacements for picnik.
the relevance of this post will obviously depend on your current and future needs/skill level

______________________________________________________


OPTION 1

REVIEW SUMMARY:
a good direct picnik replacement {not great, but good}
Accredited online photography schools recommend this for easy photo editing.



THE GOOD:
- similar interface & look to picnik - makes you feel comfortable
- easy to navigate 
- gives you a Layers option! i like this.
{the layer feature was rated as one of the top features as far as online programs go}
- great basic editing tools
- most of the same "artsy" effects 
- i LOVE the irregular crop option!
- links up to social media for sharing or grabbing pictures

THE BAD:
- overall WAY less options
- loading time seemed much longer! 
- a little disapointed in the font and collage options in particular
- collage pics need to be loaded individually
- very few stickers
- VERY limited touch up options

notes:
i did not open an account here. it is possible that there are more options if you have an account or pay for a "premium" membership like picnik. need to investigate this a little more. 
also, i could only open then save one photo at a time. again, this could change will a membership. 
if you know, please leave a comment so we can learn from each other!

_________________________________________

OPTION TWO
PIXLR 
{EXPRESS}

REVIEW SUMMARY:
a fun photo editing replacement, not good for replacing other picnik tools


THE GOOD:
- photoediting / retouch options are okay - some of my fav tools are there
- easy to navigate and use
- uploads easy
- plenty of artsy effects
- quick and easy one photo at a time kind of editing
-pic upload from computer or website
- LOTs of color filter options, which is fun

THE BAD:
- DOES NOT HAVE TEXT!
- DOES NOT HAVE COLLAGES!
- its a new program. they are working out the bugs still.
- NO sharing options. must be downloaded to a computer.
- NOT connected to any social media sites

notes:
MOST of the things that i don't like about this program can be found in the
pixlr's REGULAR program.
the regular pixlr is a GREAT program if you are planning on using a photoshop program eventually.
it has the text and collage, and all of that. BUT there is a learning curve.
the interface is similar to photoshop
& would be a great program to find out if you plan to take that leap eventually
BUT the EXPRESS as a direct replacement of picnik - i do not recommend it. 

________________________________________________________

OPTION THREE
GOOGLE + 
CREATIVE KIT

REVIEW SUMMARY:
the most like picnik, except it is only 1/2 of picnik!
but maybe its the 1/2 that you used?!


THE GOOD
- super easy interface once you FIND the creative kit
- is basicaly IS picnik {well half of picnik}
- very easy to navigate
- ALL the same basic edits
- MOST of the artsy effects are there
- ALL OF THE FONTS ARE THERE!!!
- it has some of the fun stickers which they renamed "decorate"

THE BAD
- you have to join google+ to use it. not a big deal, its similar to fb
- google + is a type of social media site - therfore anything you edit using this
program is viewed by others in your circle who you are "friends"with
- you can only edit pics that you upload to the website first,
or ones that are already in a blogger/picassa alblum
- it is about 1/2 or 1/4 of the tools that were originaly on picnik
- NO COLLAGE OPTION!

notes:
not sure how i feel about google+
it feels kinda like a wanna-be facebook.
google got rid of picnik to drive traffic to google+ & that bothers me
BUT i love thier text options. im sure i could find them somewhere else,
but i like what i am comfortable with!


OVERALL
my decision for a direct replacement of picnik,
for MY purposes will be FotoFlexer.
maybe you will pick something different, 
or use a combo of them,
but i hope this helped you!

Pin It

WANT MORE OPTIONS?
here are some
other comparision posts:
{photoscape}- recommend by a friend
{editing and collage sites}***good one
{similar sites to picnik}
{a great list of editing sites}

happy NONpicniking!
{well after april 19th i guess}
mindy starr

16 comments:

  1. Thank you so much for this great overview! I am so bummed about the loss of Picnik. I was thinking of finally learning Photoshop Elements, but I might check out the regular Pixlr program first.

    I haven't heard good things about the Google+ Creative Kit! So disappointed in that!

    Glad to have found your cute blog as well. Have a great weekend!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thanks for stopping by steph! i too think i need to dive into photoshop elements... but maybe these will be my crutch as i learn it! - mindy

      Delete
  2. Love this post! I have already started looking in a panic because I am a picnik fan and VERY disappointed. It was nice to get my subscription money returned, but I would prefer to have the product. Google is really irritating lately.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i know right?! the options are out there, but i can't find everything in one site that i like! so frustrating. i am not really a google + fan right now!

      Delete
  3. I use, and LOVE Picasa. It's free too. =)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. picassa has editing options?! i have a picassa account... i need to look into this today! thanks for sharing!

      Delete
  4. Thank you for sharing and reviewing these options. I usually use my computer's simple programs like Paint for editing and creating things. I've been thinking of upgrading to Photoshop, so it's nice to know about these other options before making a decision!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank so much for this one! I could cry-I jut got really good with my Picnik premium!http://too-much-time.com/2012/01/good-morning-sunshine-9.html

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for the research you did!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for this review. I've found that picnik's collage option isn't working well anymore since you have to upload one photo at a time now. (Perhaps it's a glitch today, or they're just overloaded now that the premium service is free) anywho, it's lovely to have information about alternatives. Thank you for sharing it.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is all so stupid - why picnik has to go away is ridiculous. If Google+ could at LEAST take all of it so we had the collage option, I could find it bearable. I don't understand why we have to broadcast ALL our pictures to our followers on Google +. I nearly freaked out when I started seeing pictures that I had on blogger 4 years ago attached to my name on Google+. That is not what I had in mind when I put them in a blogpost 4 years ago. I feel like removing picnik is just another way Google is trying to force us to use Google +. Sorry for the rant, but everytime I think about Picnik leaving I just want to cry.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Mindy, I found this post on Pinterest. Thank you so much for the overview of these programs. I feel like I just learned how to edit my pictures and now I have to re learn it on a different program. I'll be back again to check out your great blog, Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I'm so annoyed that Picnik is closing. I refuse to join Google+ again, it's just an interwebs wasteland from what I saw when I joined. I deleted my account and will not be 'forced' into signing up again just to use Picnik.
    I've found Picasa is too fiddly for my liking. Thanks for the reviews, I'll check these sites out to see how I like them. Failing that option, I'll just have to suck it up and go with Photoshop.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I bought photoshop elements when I heard the news but it is so hard to use I am discouraged! So now I had to order a tutorial from Amazon to start the training!!

    ReplyDelete
  12. What a great post, thanks for doing the work for us! I finally bought PSE and now have to learn it.

    ReplyDelete
  13. thank you for sharing this info. I too was looking for a picnik replacement and had explored a few options such as pixlr and google creative, aviary, picmonkey, before stumbling upon your article. One of my main uses for picnik was the collage function which I couldnt find anywhere, althogh I believe picmonkey has once coming soon according to their website ( although it's been saying that for ages now, so dont hold your breath ). The others are just not suitable at all, so I tried fotoflexer as you suggested, and low and behold, a collage function, wehey. Unfortunately it's a bit of a pain as you mentioned, having to upload each photo seperately is very tedious, but even more annoying is the pop-ups that appear all over the place. Its ok for now until something better comes along....... thanks for your help.

    ReplyDelete